The future for the West in Afghanistan is bleak, and it is made more discouraging by the fact that much of the West’s defeat will be self-inflicted because it did not adequately study the lessons of history.
Così Michael Scheuer, analista di intelligence della Jamestown Foundation, su Asia Times di oggi. Per Scheuer, la storia afghana, l’indole guerriera delle sue componenti tribali, e la “impenetrabile topografia” del Paese sono alla base del disastro che si profila:
In the most general sense, the defeat of Western forces in Afghanistan occurs repeatedly because the West has not developed an appreciation for the Afghans’ toughness, patience, resourcefulness and pride in their history. Although foreign forces in Afghanistan are always more modern and better armed and trained, they are continuously ground down by the same kinds of small-scale but unrelenting hit-and-run attacks and ambushes, as well as by the country’s impenetrable topography that allows the Afghans to retreat, hide, and attack another day.
Inoltre, la collocazione geopolitica del paese rende difficile una proiezione di forza sufficiente per le potenze che cercano di domarne la resistenza e la riottosità.
[…] Western forces - while better armed and technologically superior - are far too few in number. Today’s Western force totals about 40,000 troops. After subtracting support troops and North Atlantic Treaty Organization contingents that are restricted to non-combat, reconstruction roles - building schools, digging wells, repairing irrigation systems - the actual combat force that can be fielded on any given day is far smaller, and yet has the task of controlling a country the size of Texas that is home to some of the highest mountains on Earth.